MUSE Platinum

2024

Make Up Over Makeup

Entrant Company

Madwell

Category

Social Media - Celebrity & Influencer

Client's Name

e.l.f. Cosmetics

Country / Region

United States

The premise of e.l.f.’s latest content series “Make Up Over Makeup” was to get two people with a public falling out to come together and apply each other’s makeup – an activity that is naturally disarming. Can these two people actually make up while applying each other’s makeup? We set to find out in our inaugural episode starring famous TikTok exes Chris Olsen and Ian Paget, a pair we knew our fans would go crazy for.

Chris and Ian skyrocketed to TikTok fame during the pandemic thanks to their viral videos that documented their relationship. But when Gen Z’s favorite “comfort couple” broke up, it left their millions of fans devastated and searching for answers. We saw a huge opportunity for e.l.f. to demonstrate our values and give our fans the closure they craved.

The reunion was exactly what you’d expect from two exes who hadn’t seen each other in a year: awkward, funny, juicy, yet deeply healing. Chris and Ian brought their signature sparkle and banter that their fans know and love, and reflected on their relationship. All the while, e.l.f. skincare and makeup products were there as a tool to facilitate conversation and connection between the two.

And it worked. Fans flocked to the full episode on YouTube in droves. They even went off-platform from TikTok to YouTube and back to TikTok again to talk about it! With $0 in paid media, Episode 1 had a social reach of 72.1M and an Instagram engagement rate of +2300%. The full YouTube episode even shot to #16 on a global list of trending videos. Fans sang our praises in the comments and even wished the episode was longer! It’s all thanks to us having a strong understanding of our audience and the kind of talent that would resonate with them. The success of Episode 1 lead to "Make Up Over Makeup" being greenlit into a series, with another successful episode under our belt starring Vanderpump Rules frenemies, Katie Maloney and Scheana Shay.

Stay tuned for Episode 3, because we’re just getting started.

Credits

Co-Founder & CCO / Madwell
Chris Sojka
President / Madwell
Gabriela Benitez
Head of Business Leadership / Madwell
Keisy Bisono
Head of Licensing & Partnerships / Madwell
Sean Holland
Creative Director / Madwell
Mauricio Galván
Associate Creative Director / Madwell
Alex Kaufman
Associate Creative Director / Madwell
Libby Dean
Senior Animator / Madwell
Scotty Nolan
Designer / Madwell
Zenzile Sky Lark
Senior Copywriter / Madwell
Kaitlin Bowen
Vice President, Production / Madwell
Brigid McEntee
Group Strategy Director / Madwell
Naya Mukherji
Group Comms Strategy Director / Madwell
Darren Allison
Social Strategist / Madwell
Madison Allen
Director / Starfish
Chris Sojka
Head of Content / Starfish
Jenita Spirtovic
CMO, e.l.f. Beauty & President, Keys Soulcare
Kory Marchisotto
Chief Creative Officer / e.l.f. Beauty
Ashley Rosebrook
Chief Brand Officer / e.l.f. Beauty
Laurie Lam
Vice President, Integrated Marketing Communications / e.l.f. Beauty
Patrick O’Keefe
Senior Director, Brand Marketing / e.l.f. Beauty
Brooklyn Boston
Director, Integrated Marketing Communications / e.l.f. Beauty
Alex Kasper
More Platinum Winners
Event
2024
MUSE Advertising Awards - 2023 Upfront

Entrant Company

NBCUniversal

Category

Event - B2B Event

Country / Region

United States

Marketing & Promotional
2024
MUSE Advertising Awards - Yeah The Boys Short Film Key Art

Entrant Company

barlow.agency

Category

Marketing & Promotional - Poster (Single)

Country / Region

Australia

Branded Content
2024
MUSE Advertising Awards - Hyundai - Frosted Tips Podcast Roadtrip To IHRMF

Entrant Company

iHeartmedia

Category

Branded Content - Auto & Auto Services

Country / Region

United States

Integrated Marketing
2024
MUSE Advertising Awards - The Power of We

Entrant Company

Intermountain Health

Category

Integrated Marketing - Brand Transformation / Repositioning

Country / Region

United States